I think we share virtually all the same goals and ideas that Wikimedia does. If there’s any massive difference, it is that we try to concentrate on paper output. People who’re touring don’t all the time have ready access to a pc – it can be nice to have printed guides.
On prime of this you might have the pointed SEO challenges, outlined by Sam Daams above — the loss of a truckload of inbound hyperlinks which most likely contribute a not-insignificant human site visitors stream alongwith a substantial potential duplicate content material issue. Sure NewWikiTravel will beat IB over the head with their valuable anti-aggressive Wikipedia links and I assume many of the active contributors will be in the boat as well.
The most likely option is thus establishment: IB will hold doing the one factor it may, squeezing every final drop of revenue from visitors venturing in, and possibly turning up the infomercial volume to eleven. But with the community quickly to turn into a ghost city, and increasing numbers of spammers and vandals dropping in to trash the place with nobody left to scrub up after them, they are going to most likely need to disable editing ultimately, and the positioning will die a slow, ignominious death.
If Wikitravel contained that type of commentary, along with actual photos of locations folks have stayed, it will be twice as useful as it’s right this moment. In Wikitravel’s defense, its operators probably fear that if the positioning invited customers to post strong opinions, it would quickly sink into flame wars over whether Khao San Road is a charming open-market road or a debauched vacationer gutter. And Wikitravel is striving for one thing larger than the amicable give-and-take on Travelfish: The creation of one definitive evaluation that displays the overlapping consensus of many several types of individuals.
The free encyclopedia often dominates the upper tiers of Google search results pages, and the launch of a nonetheless-unnamed Wikimedia travel information may have substantial implications for travelers seeking free vacation spot advice — and guidebook publishers similar to LonelyPlanet — if the brand new venture garners any sort of comparable clout.